This put up first appeared for premium subscribers of Nice Management on Substack and was revealed on October 27, 2023. If you wish to get entry to unique articles like this one and weekly 5 min management ideas, then make certain to grow to be a premium subscriber and get all of my greatest content material and newest pondering delivered to your inbox. Be taught extra and enroll right here. Premium subscribers get content material like this each week.
…
Should you’re a Chief Human Sources or Chief Folks Officer, then you’ll be able to request to hitch a model new group I put collectively known as Future Of Work Leaders which focuses on the way forward for work and worker expertise. Be a part of leaders from Tractor Provide, Johnson & Johnson, Lego, Dow, Northrop Grumman and plenty of others. We come collectively just about every month and annually in-person to sort out large themes that transcend conventional HR.
I’ve been engaged on growing a excessive stage management scorecard that I can use to judge enterprise leaders all over the world. Periodically, my purpose is to evaluation a brand new chief and break down how the chief scores on the entire parts in addition to give an general LEADER rating. My hope is that not solely will this generate dialogue however may also assist you to in your profession and management journey.
This LEADER scorecard will ONLY be accessible for premium subscribers of Nice Management. Should you aren’t a subscriber but, then I encourage you to enroll, it’s just a few {dollars} a month.
First, right here’s a breakdown of what the scorecard appears to be like like. I anticipate that additional time it’d change a bit nevertheless it’s additionally one thing that you should utilize to judge your personal leaders.
L = Lengthy-term imaginative and prescient and technique: That is basic for any chief. The flexibility to examine the longer term and strategize accordingly is essential for guiding a staff or group towards success.
-
1-3: Unclear or inconsistent imaginative and prescient and technique.
-
4-6: Imaginative and prescient and technique are outlined however not successfully communicated or carried out.
-
7-10: Clear imaginative and prescient and technique which can be well-communicated, constantly carried out, and aligned with organizational targets.
E = Worker expertise and engagement: Recognizing the significance of worker well-being and their engagement ranges signifies an understanding that management isn’t nearly top-down choices, but in addition about fostering a optimistic work atmosphere.
-
1-3: Low ranges of worker satisfaction, engagement, and dedication.
-
4-6: Reasonable ranges of worker satisfaction; some areas want enchancment.
-
7-10: Excessive ranges of worker satisfaction, engagement, and dedication with proactive measures to take care of them
A = Adaptability and innovation: In a quickly altering world, a pacesetter’s capability to adapt and innovate is significant. This component displays the significance of being proactive and responsive to vary.
-
1-3: Resistant to vary; restricted innovation efforts.
-
4-6: Some efforts to adapt and innovate however missing consistency or clear route.
-
7-10: Actively promotes a tradition of adaptability and constant innovation.
D = Determination making: Central to management is the power to make choices—generally underneath strain, typically with incomplete info. A frontrunner’s judgment and decision-making functionality is a key determinant of success.
-
1-3: Determination-making is sluggish, unstructured, or missing transparency.
-
4-6: Choices are made however would possibly lack full stakeholder enter or data-driven insights.
-
7-10: Choices are well timed, data-driven, and contain related stakeholders.
E = Exemplary conduct and function modeling: Leaders set the tone for a corporation’s tradition. Their actions, values, and behaviors can encourage and affect these round them.
-
1-3: Management behaviors are inconsistent with organizational values.
-
4-6: Management generally shows exemplary conduct, however inconsistencies exist.
-
7-10: Management constantly fashions desired behaviors and values, setting a optimistic instance for all.
R = Outcomes and metrics: On the finish of the day, leaders are sometimes judged by the outcomes they obtain. This component ensures a deal with tangible outcomes and data-driven assessments.
-
1-3: Restricted use of metrics; outcomes are beneath expectations.
-
4-6: Makes use of metrics however would possibly lack alignment with strategic targets; outcomes meet some expectations.
-
7-10: Metrics are strategically aligned, and outcomes constantly meet or exceed expectations.
At the moment, I’m going to be Elon Musk, the founder/CEO of firms together with Tesla, SpaceX, X, and The Boring Firm. He’s at present the world’s richest man with an estimated web value of $250 billion
Born in Pretoria, South Africa, in 1971, Musk has emerged as one of the vital influential figures in expertise, house exploration, and sustainable vitality. Musk’s endeavors typically resemble the bold feats of science fiction. But, repeatedly, he has turned his visionary concepts into tangible realities. Whether or not celebrated as a forward-thinking genius or criticized for his audacious proclamations, there’s no denying that Musk’s contributions proceed to form the trajectory of the fashionable world.
If you would like me to do extra posts like this then please let me know within the feedback part and it’s also possible to recommend different leaders for me to evaluation
Let’s break down the entire LEADER parts and see if Elon Musk is really an important chief and why or why not.
Lengthy-term imaginative and prescient and technique
Elon Musk is broadly regarded for his long-term imaginative and prescient and technique. From the creation of Tesla with the mission to speed up the world’s transition to sustainable vitality, to SpaceX’s purpose of colonizing Mars, Musk’s endeavors constantly revolve round bold and long-term targets. His capability to speak these visions has mobilized important assets and public curiosity. Should you check out his core ares of focus they revolve across the following:
-
Pioneering A Sustainable Future
-
Past Earth
-
The Ecosystem Technique
-
A New Imaginative and prescient of Transportation
-
The Free-Speech Tremendous App
A lot of leaders have large goals and aspirations however what units Elon Musk aside isn’t just the dimensions of his goals however his capability to govt on them. This includes difficult norms, private and monetary sacrifices, and an unyielding dedication to his strategic aims.
In essence, Musk’s long-term imaginative and prescient and technique mix groundbreaking aspirations with pragmatic execution. Whether or not it’s revolutionizing roads, redefining aerospace, or envisioning interplanetary life, Musk’s strategic acumen frequently pushes the boundaries of chance. One problem right here is that generally his targets can appear overly bold which might trigger groups to overextend or set unrealistic expectations, for instance his predictions for autonomous driving which have been delayed a number of instances.
It’s exhausting to think about a pacesetter as efficient at each growing and executing on a long-term imaginative and prescient and technique.
Rating 10/10
Worker expertise and engagement
That is the realm the place Elon Musk struggles with probably the most. Elon has a famend work ethic, oftentimes working over 100 hours every week and sleeping underneath his desk. He’s infamous for the extent of depth he brings and the expectations he units on these round him which isn’t essentially a nasty factor, nevertheless it’s actually not for everybody. He has completely developed a passionate work tradition the place the individuals who work at his firms know they should work extraordinarily exhausting. Nevertheless the problem is that Elon thinks everybody else can and needs to work like Elon.
Musk is clearly mission pushed and communicates that mission to his staff, giving them one thing to rally behind. He’s concerned in management, and is ready to unlock the total potential of the individuals who work for him.
Nevertheless, quite a few studies and tales have emerged over time over his non-human working situations and the way he treats folks. For instance the way through which he fired his staff at X, his mood and ego the place he can explode on his staff, and the lengthy hours and all-in dedication he calls for. A Forbes article truly mentioned that “Elon Musk views folks as collateral injury as a substitute of as human beings.” He additionally isn’t identified to have excessive ranges of emotional intelligence and that’s certainly one of his large critiques. However, we also needs to keep in mind that was identified with Asperger’s syndrome which is related to difficulties in social interation.
Quite a few excessive rating executives have left after working quick stints for Elon (CFO, VP engineering, and so on). Musk additionally generally makes use of X as a method to announce issues and make choices earlier than even telling them to staff which causes communication challenges and chaotic work environments.
Taking a look at Glassdoor rankings Tesla has a 3.6/5 the place solely 70% of worker approve of Elon Musk as CEO and solely 60% of staff would advocate working there to a buddy. Twitter is way decrease at 3.2/5 by way of CEO approval (just lately modified to Linda Yaccarino), solely 35% advocate the corporate to a buddy and there’s solely a 23% approval ranking. SpaceX gala’s barely higher with a 3.8/5 general ranking the place 70% would advocate the corporate to a buddy and Elon has an 84% approval ranking.
Rating 6/10
Adaptability and innovation
Time and time once more Elon Musk has demonstrated his capability to adapt, problem the established order, and innovate with new options and concepts. He has performed this in each single trade has been concerned in starting from house exploration to electrical automobiles. There isn’t an organization or trade Elon Musk has gotten concerned in that has generate sever disruption and large world influence.
Listed below are a number of of issues has has performed:
-
SpaceX and Reusable Rockets: SpaceX, revolutionized house journey with the introduction of reusable rockets. This innovation lowered the price of accessing house, marking a big leap ahead in making house journey extra possible for numerous purposes. Earlier than SpaceX’s efforts, the concept of touchdown and reusing rockets was seen as unattainable.
-
Tesla’s Electrical Automobiles: Musk’s insistence on transitioning the world to sustainable vitality led to the start of Tesla, which introduced electrical vehicles to the forefront of the automotive trade. With fashions just like the Roadster, Mannequin S, and Mannequin 3, Tesla defied skeptics who believed electrical vehicles couldn’t match the efficiency or vary of their gasoline counterparts. Not solely that, his vehicles are sensible, stunning, and the Y has just lately grow to be the #1 best-selling automobile in America, a primary for an electrical automobile.
-
SolarCity and Sustainable Power: SolarCity (now part of Tesla Power) aimed to offer sustainable vitality options. The corporate’s photo voltaic panels and Powerwall models are examples of improvements that goal to scale back the world’s reliance on fossil fuels.
-
Hyperloop: Musk proposed the concept of the Hyperloop, a high-speed transportation system utilizing near-vacuum tubes through which pods may journey. Whereas he has not developed it personally, his proposal impressed a flurry of analysis and improvement worldwide.
-
Neuralink: Venturing into the realm of neuroscience, Musk co-founded Neuralink with the purpose of facilitating brain-computer interfaces. This could possibly be revolutionary in treating neurological issues and enhancing human cognition.
-
ChatGPT: Few folks understand that the startup which created ChatGPT was truly funded by Elon Musk to the tune of $50 million.
Including to this listing we are able to embrace The Boring Firm which is geared toward enhancing transportation through using underground tunnels and X which is able to finally grow to be the “every thing app” in accordance with Elon.
Nevertheless, Musk didn’t get to the place he’s with out having to beat obstacles and adapting. Each Tesla and SpaceX at one level confronted potential chapter and Musk needed to make investments a substantial portion of his private funds to maintain the businesses afloat. You might also recall that in 2014 Musk introduced that he would open supply al of the Tesla patents, a lot of which you’ll be able to see right here on Github.
Rating 10/10
…
Management is evolving quickly—are you maintaining? Annually, I interact with and analyze the insights of main executives from firms like Microsoft, IBM, and Virgin Group, uncovering the methods that drive their success. This unique PDF distills the highest 5 management hacks utilized by these world-renowned leaders. Uncover what units these leaders aside and how one can apply their breakthrough ways to raise your management in 2024 and past.
…
Determination making
Elon Musk actually makes errors and his determination making has been each closely criticized but additionally lauded. No chief makes good choices 100% of the time. One of many large challenges Elon Musk faces is that he issues in public, particularly on X. As I discussed above he’ll share controversial views and views and oftentimes make enterprise choices earlier than even telling his staff about it.
In a current revealed by INC journal the authors level out that Elon Musk as (quoted from the article):
-
Ask a query.
-
Collect as a lot proof as doable about it.
-
Develop axioms based mostly on the proof, and attempt to assign a chance of reality to every one.
-
Draw a conclusion based mostly on cogency in an effort to decide: Are these axioms right, are they related, do they essentially result in this conclusion, and with what chance?
-
Try to disprove the conclusion. Search refutation from others to additional assist break your conclusion.
-
If no person can invalidate your conclusion, you then’re most likely proper, however you’re not actually proper.
He additionally subscribes to “first rules pondering” which is about breaking issues down into small components, basic truths, and keep away from reasoning by analogy. In article revealed by creator James Clear, he provides the next quoted instance:
“I are inclined to strategy issues from a physics framework,” Musk mentioned in an interview. “Physics teaches you to motive from first rules moderately than by analogy. So I mentioned, okay, let’s take a look at the primary rules. What’s a rocket made from? Aerospace-grade aluminum alloys, plus some titanium, copper, and carbon fiber. Then I requested, what’s the worth of these supplies on the commodity market? It turned out that the supplies value of a rocket was round two % of the everyday value.”
As a substitute of shopping for a completed rocket for tens of tens of millions, Musk determined to create his personal firm, buy the uncooked supplies for reasonable, and construct the rockets himself. SpaceX was born.”
Right here’s a nice however outdated video the place Elon Musk explains this in his personal phrases. Taking this strategy permits Musk to problem prevailing beliefs and traditional knowledge about something and every thing, thus resulting in higher innovation.
Elon Musk can also be identified to take calculated dangers, all of which have to this point paid off apart from X which as of now could be an enormous loss for him, however, it stays to be seen what is going to grow to be of the platform within the coming years. Bear in mind, each Tesla and SpaceX have been at one level close to bankrupt.
Along with a wholesome skepticism in the direction of conformity Elon Musk additionally embraces steady suggestions from each his staff and most people through X. He doesn’t all the time reply to the suggestions in one of the simplest ways however it may be argued that no different chief takes in as a lot suggestions as Elon. Musk can also be somebody who stands by the selections he makes. He takes accountability and doesn’t cross the blame to anybody else. Even within the case of X, he joked that he was working the world’s largest non-profit, clearly a joke he made at his personal expense, acknowledging the problem he faces with turning the corporate round.
Musk makes higher general strategic enterprise choices than he does micro stage choices. Many of the criticism he has acquired over the previous few years in relation to his determination making is in relation to X. Collectively his choices have let to huge success.
Rating 8/10
Exemplary conduct and function modeling
That is one other space the place Elon Musk struggles fairly a bit. In some methods Elon Musk is a implausible function mannequin for entrepreneurs and leaders. He got here from a tough background as a younger boy in South Africa the place he was bullied and achieved huge success. Elon is the exemplar of all issues associated to work ethic, exhausting work, ardour, grit and willpower. He conquers all of the obstacles that come his approach, disrupts something he touches, and stands by his values and choices.
However exemplary conduct and function modeling for leaders is greater than concerning the enterprise choices and influence they make. It’s additionally about how the chief treats others and behaves not simply in knowledgeable setting however in a private one as properly. One clear detrimental instance right here is how Musk let go of hundreds of staff at X in a moderately merciless and ruthless approach.
Right here’s an in-depth Vainness Truthful article which highlights among the issues Elon Musk has performed which don’t bode properly for optimistic management conduct together with bullying his staff, making inappropriate private and non-private feedback, and assuming everyone seems to be a workaholic like he’s and placing those self same pressures on staff.
Peter Thiel as soon as mentioned that Elon Musk was a detrimental function mannequin as a result of he was too exhausting to emulate.
Would I would like my youngsters to emulate and look as much as Elon Musk? When it comes to how he approaches enterprise, for probably the most half, sure. When it comes to how Elon treats others and himself? Not as a lot.
Rating 6/10
Outcomes and metrics
Within the enterprise world there isn’t a substitute for having the ability to ship, aka delivering outcomes. In contrast to most different enterprise leaders, Elon Musk has his hand in lots of many cookie jars, a few of which have been outlined above.
Not the entire endeavors Musk is concerned in are public by way of the outcomes they’ve achieved, the targets they’ve, and the metrics they’re utilizing to measure success.
Tesla alone has round 130,000 staff all over the world and in case you mix the headcount of his different firms it’s round 150,000. Having the ability to create jobs and supply a livelihood for that many individuals is actually no small feat.
The one firm the place we are able to see publicly accessible monetary information is Tesla as a result of it’s the one public traded firm. Tesla most just lately missed on each income and earnings of their newest name and the Cybertruck appears to be working into loads of points by way of scale and manufacturing. Nonetheless, the corporate general has performed fairly properly over time and the problems the corporate is dealing with look like on account of excessive demand, which isn’t a nasty factor within the long-term.
X as of now remains to be a monetary catastrophe nevertheless it’s not a public firm so the knowledge is a bit exhausting to come back by. Musk fired round 80% of the employees and when he took over the corporate had $13 billion in debt. It stays to be seen what is going to occur to the corporate.
The income for OpenAI (the corporate behind ChatGPT) has skyrocketed to over $1.3 billion and I anticipate that can proceed to develop. Musk isn’t in any formal management function however he did fund the corporate to get it off the bottom.
SpaceX turned revenue in 2023 after reporting to subsequent annual general losses. In accordance with Reuters, “The corporate generated $55 million in revenue on $1.5 billion in income in the course of the January-to-March interval.”
With reference to his different companies reminiscent of Nueralink, Hyperloop, and The Boring Firm, these are nonetheless early stage companies whose main purpose is make extra of a societal and human influence versus a enterprise influence (for now). It’s exhausting to judge them by way of monetary success however not less than Nueralink appears to creating robust strides in merging people with AI!
General, Elon Musk is ready to generate outcomes for the companies he’s concerned in. Once more, he’s a little bit of an anomaly since he’s concerned in so many firms and solely certainly one of them are public. With Tesla underperforming a bit these days and projections being over promised and underdelivered, X being massively in debt, and SpaceX barely seeing a revenue, there’s something left to be desired.
Rating 7/10
Elon Musk is undoubtedly one of the vital visionary leaders of our time and he has made extra of an influence on our society than most human beings. Like all leaders, Elon Musk has his strengths and weaknesses. Whereas he excels in all areas of technique, innovation, creativity, and flexibility, he struggles in relation to the human points of labor.
Do you agree with this evaluation? Why or why not? Go away a remark beneath and let me know.
General rating: 47/60
If you would like me to do extra posts like this then please let me know within the feedback part and it’s also possible to recommend different leaders for me to evaluation.
…
Management is evolving quickly—are you maintaining? Annually, I interact with and analyze the insights of main executives from firms like Microsoft, IBM, and Virgin Group, uncovering the methods that drive their success. This unique PDF distills the highest 5 management hacks utilized by these world-renowned leaders. Uncover what units these leaders aside and how one can apply their breakthrough ways to raise your management in 2024 and past.
